Observations of life by author and poet Charles L. Chatmon
Note: I wrote this back in August 2006, but don't see it posted on the blog list. I hope you like. Enjoy.
I read where former civil-rights leader and Atlanta mayor Andrew Young stepped down from a post at Wal-Mart. The post was to help Wal-Mart improve its public image which the retail giant has come under fire in recent years. However, Mr. Young stepped out of the line of racial fire by resigning his post, and it was a good thing too. No matter how factual his statements were, it just goes to prove every time the truths of the community’s ills are mentioned, feet are stepped on and nerves are touched. Here is what he said during an interview with the L. A. Sentinel, one of the oldest black newspapers in Los Angeles, he answered a question if he was concerned whether or not the retail giant caused the smaller mom and pop stores to close down:
"Well, I think they should; they ran the 'mom and pop' stores out of my neighborhood," the paper quoted Young as saying. "But you see, those are the people who have been overcharging us, selling us stale bread and bad meat and wilted vegetables. And they sold out and moved to Florida. I think they've ripped off our communities enough. First it was Jews, then it was Koreans and now it's Arabs; very few black people own these stores."
Young apologized for his comments and resigned from his Wal-Mart post shortly thereafter. It is my hope that everyone looks past the races he mentioned, and takes a look at the larger issue here, while reading his words myself, tried to express but taken the wrong way.
There was a time during the 1992 unrest where politicians, corporations and civil leaders pledged to ‘Rebuild L.A.’. I imagine no one read the fine print on which specific section of the city would be renovated because if you look closely, the only area that I can see that is being rebuilt is downtown. I’m sure that’s the case in many metropolitan areas where the urban communities are facing their share of retail neglect. Perhaps the only people who should shout loudly on this topic are the people who were promised that all of L.A., including its improvised neighborhoods, be renovated. But I digress.
There is a grain of truth in what Mr. Young said. “very black people own these stores.”, meaning the mom and pop stores in the community. As I have explained before, growing up on the streets of South Los Angeles back in the 1980’s, I had the feeling of being a stranger to my own community. I visited stores owned by merchants who didn’t reflect where I lived; their interests were different than mine, their store policies, etc. One of my long term dreams is to eventually own a store in the community, but when if you happen to look around at the empty vacant lots and notice the ‘for sale’ signs on the land, you’ll discover the owners of said properties don’t live in the area and are of a different ethnic background than I. I’ll just hazard a big guess here, but part of the reason why the Vermont Knolls area was left untouched for fourteen years was because previous owners of the land either refused to sell or set their property at such a high price that it was impossible for anyone to acquire it. I’d love to hear from anyone who has more experience on the subject. However, during my years of being a citizen of the area, that’s the best I can come up with and I’m sticking to that theory until further notice.
When we have something that belongs to ‘us’, we sure better support it and not squander it, especially not now because there is enough money to go around. It’s just not coming back to the urban neighborhoods fast enough. If you take away the specific ethnic groups Mr. Young mentioned, the conclusion is very clear; there are different players, but the game remains the same. Citizens living in urban areas continually get left out when it comes to retail.
Of course you’ll have civic and religious leaders calling Mr. Young’s comments, ‘insensitive’, ‘condescending’, and ‘racist’. The only groups of people who will be affected by his words are the same citizens living in urban areas where fewer mom and pop stores remain. Think about it; his comments may have been offensive, but will that change the fact that no giant retailers will continue to stay away from the community; that the very few corporate retailers in the area now will continue to set high prices for their products, forcing residents to pay more? Add to the fact as people of color continue to drive out of their neighborhoods to find a retailer for food and/or clothing, will that in fact dilute the mom and pop stores even further?
What is ironic about Mr. Young’s former employer is that two years ago they were involved in a fight with Inglewood merchants over this very same topic. Anyone remember Proposition 4-A? I spoke about it in an earlier entry, ‘The Perception of a Black Neighborhood.” Check it out.
Mr. Young said it best when he spoke about the reaction his comments might generate:
"Things that are matter-of-fact in Atlanta, in the New York and Los Angeles environment, tend to be a lot more volatile,"
All that being said, at the end of this day, a few tempers will rise but everything will remain the same. Urban neighborhoods in major metropolitan cities will continue to receive less and less financially while other corporate interests, different ethnic groups will thrive due to those same shoppers in the community.
Unfortunately for the mom and pop stores still in existence, that’s offensive enough.